Positive and Effective Reactions to Anti-LGBT Behavior
So I (I, Adam, the kid who's writing this) went to the GLSEN Boston annual conference last Saturday. I took a workshop called "You Can't Say That!", run by an awesome woman called Shantanette Patrice.
Here are my notes! It was a pretty interactive sort of workshop, so I imagine it changes every time she runs it, but I had a nice time and learned quite a bit.
Some initial thoughts on addressing anti-LGBT comments
- A diplomatic, political way to address without attacking
- Keeping it positive, keeping it going
- Not just "shutting them up", if you can avoid it; actually conversing
- Be preventative
- Think about what not to do/say
- Address the root of the problem—more than a "band-aid" quick fix
- Try not to be aggressive or outright mean, not to their face, anyway
- Not implying anything about, or defining, the victim in the situation. (For example, "It's okay that he's gay." Well, maybe he's not gay; don't assume.)
- Not just "I can't say 'fag' around this person who yells at me for saying it"—I can't say it around ANYONE, and I shouldn't. That's the attitude that needs to be there.
First response when dealing with this kind of situation
- Check your own feelings. Are you okay?
- Will you use your voice? Use it well.
- Make the situation BETTER, don't just break it up or even make worse
And then three courses of action:
Immediate
- Stop. The. Behavior. Period.
- Be polite. Your feelings are not the issue; the ISSUE (i.e. oppression, prejudice) is the issue
- What does this person really mean to say, and why?
Interm
- Offer alternative
- So why shouldn't you say [x] anyway? What's wrong with it?
- Lots of why, how, what do you mean, what does this imply
- Checking in with everyone involved, subtly
- Use humor without dismissing
Ongoing
- Education
- Get people off the defensive
- Engage, be willing to answer questions. You opened the situation up by telling them not to be homophobic. A command doesn't really get you anywhere, whereas discussion just may
- "Do you want to prove something?" "Is there something you want to say to me?" What is the homophobic person thinking, feeling, questioning?
- Stress similarities—it's about disarming. "But I have a right to my opinion!" Validate them. "Yes, certainly. Telling you what to feel is completely out of line. But I am not telling you to feel a certain way. With your words you're invading people's rights, their spaces, their territory. (explain how) All I ask you to do is to keep it to yourself."
A sobering thought
"You are the fag"; you could be that "fag." So talk.
